Wednesday, August 21, 2013

78 Biggest Challenges to Evolution - General Overview

Here is the following list I have compiled. I will be continuing to develop these one at a time in future blogs. I want to be able to write both the Naturalistic (Evolutionary) view and the Biblical Creation view of each of these topics (including the research), so your input as we continue with this study would be good.

Be thinking as you read through this list and may God Bless You!        -Brian
 
78 Biggest Challenges to Evolution - General Overview

Geology/Paleontology/Archaeology

1.       Dinosaurs

a.       Where are missing links between lizards and dinosaurs?

b.      Where are missing links between dinosaurs and birds?

c.       Many claim that birds have evolved from dinosaurs. Were birds around before and during the time of dinosaurs?

d.      Reptiles and Birds have completely different lung systems.

e.      How did feathers evolve?

f.        Evolution between cold blooded and warm blooded (maybe)?

g.       How do we explain dragon legends and depictions of dinosaurs all over the world before we found fossils of dinosaurs?

h.      How did they die? Why not other animals?

i.         How do we explain soft tissue being found in Dinosaurs if they died out about 65 million years ago?

 

2.       The Cambrian Explosion and Punctuated Equilibrium

a.       How did the earlier organisms evolve into different types and the vast amount of new forms?

b.      Where are the evolutionary links?

c.       How did it happen so fast?

d.      What environmental change could have done that?

e.      How do we know how long it took?

f.        Why do we see so much catastrophe?

 

3.       Missing Links

a.       From Water to Land initially? (Legged Fish)

b.      From Land to Water? (Cow-like à whales)

c.       Giraffe?

d.      Platypus?

e.      Dinosaurs?

f.        Birds?

g.       Etc.

 

4.       Index Fossils

a.       Index Fossils are used to date rock layers. The rock layer a fossil is in dates the fossil. This is circular reasoning and based on assumptions. How do we know how old something is?

b.      Can we trust radiometric dating? (see below)

c.       There are many index fossils that they used to say pointed to millions of years ago that were found alive today like the Coelacanth and Gingko Trees.

 

5.       Large Fossils

a.       There are many large fossils that show that the climate and air pressure and air quality must have been different in the past.

b.      How is this possible?

                                                               i.      This could be evidence of the canopy theory. (see below)

 

6.       Evolution of Feathers

a.       Feathers are very complex. Did they evolve from scales or hair?

b.      How did such minute, complex structures evolve?

c.       There is no conclusive evidence yet of dinosaurs with feathers or of the evolution of feathers in general.

 

7.       Human Ancestors

a.       Civilization appeared to pop out of nowhere around 2000 BC and dates and records before that tend toward more guesswork the further back in time you go.

b.      Evidences of these human ancestors are often hoaxed or shaky at best.

 

8.       Rock Layers

a.       Folds and Bends that indicate the rock layers were soft all at once.

b.      Jumbled fossils, full mass fossil beds are evidence of a large flood.

c.       Sandstone injectites or columns that came up through many layers of rock.

d.      Large layers spread across continents.

e.      Evidence of large strong water currents (cross-bedding) throughout rock layers

f.        If rock layers formed slowly over long periods of time, why are they as consistent as they are? Rock layers would not have formed this nicely and completely over long periods of time, if they did, we ought to see more erosion in the layers. A quick burial and formation of layers makes more sense than ancient seas at different times all over the world.

g.       If rock layers formed over millions of year or at least long spurts of time in between new layers, we would expect to see erosion within the layers. Instead we see very smooth, consistent layers laid perfectly on top of each other and even bending (would have been soft) right on top of each other.

 

9.       Underwater Ruins

a.       There are many ruins all around the coasts that some appear to be built around the time of 2200-1500 BC, which fits with the lower sea levels due to the ice age after the great flood. How does a long age theory fit these findings?

 

10.   Mt St Helens

a.       This event shows us recorded and observable knowledge that we can study about really quick catastrophic events and the results of that event. Because of the eruption of Mt St Helens:

                                                              i.      Canyons formed quickly

                                                            ii.      Layers of sediment were laid down

                                                          iii.      A vertical tree forest now sits at the bottom of Spirit lake similar to petrified forests found in rock layers today.

 

11.   Mass Rapid Fossil Beds

a.       These are evidence that a lot of creatures were buried rapidly and smashed together in what looks like the result of a large flood.

b.      Petrified trees sticking through many layers of rock.

c.       Evidence of a Fish eating another fish – burial was immediate.

d.      Unopened clam fossils. (They open when the clam dies.)

e.      Many animals tend to be in suffocating, throw positions.

f.        Animals that die today are hardly ever fossilized.

 

12.   Silt/Salt Deposits

a.       These deposits could not have formed by multiple periods of evaporation thus leaving layers of salt and silt. These deposits are so large and so pure that they are more of an indication of solubility changes in a large body of water.

 

13.   Erosion Examples

a.       There are many examples of erosion that make sense with a recent global flood resulting in:

                                                              i.      sheet erosion

                                                            ii.      then channelized erosion

                                                          iii.      as well as many other examples of rapid flood deposits.

                                                           iv.      If evolution were true, the continents should be eroded down since current rates of erosion are greater than mountain building rates.

 

14.   Cave Formation and Structure

a.       Caves did not have to form over long periods of time and there are a few examples of rapid cave formations taking place today.

                                                              i.      Naica Crystals

                                                            ii.      Bat in a stalagmite

                                                          iii.      Milwaukee Public Museum stalactites

b.      Simply more water and the right conditions are needed for faster cave formation rates.

 

15.   Petrification

a.       This is the process of turning an object into stone. There are many of examples that show how this would have had to happen fast, such as:

                                                              i.      petrified trees

                                                            ii.      a bowler hat

                                                          iii.      a teddy bear

                                                           iv.      Petrified ham

                                                             v.      Petrified foot in a cowboy boot

                                                           vi.      and even poop (coprolite)

 

16.   Radiometric Dating

a.       This is the process that analyzes how the parent isotope breaks down to the daughter isotopes within the rocks.

b.      There are many assumptions.

c.       There is good evidence to show that it is not as reliable as it should be.

                                                              i.      Mount St. Helens

                                                            ii.      Grand Canyon

                                                          iii.      Hawaii Lava Flows

                                                           iv.      Living Things dated as really old!

 

17.   Ice Age

a.       The great global flood created the cooling and the right conditions to cause the ice age.

                                                              i.      Long age scientists have challenges to getting the right conditions to cause the ice age.

b.      There is no good evidence of multiple ice ages.

 

Biology/Genetics/Anatomy

18.   Irreducible Complexity (Impossibly Complex)

a.       There are countless examples of organisms that are too complex to have evolved.

b.      Especially as our technology becomes more advanced, and our studies dive deeper and deeper and closer and closer, we see everything still becoming more complex than we even had realized before.

c.       Current scientists and engineers look to the amazing complexity of life for better technology and engineering.

d.      A mousetrap could not exist without one of its parts. The slow processes of evolution are very unlikely.

 

19.   Symbiotic Relationships

a.       There are many examples of two organisms that use each other and help each other survive and in many cases they could not live without each other. How could this have evolved?

 

20.    Natural Selection and Microevolution

a.       This is change within a species. The physical results of a gene or a mutation are changed and the environmental factors choose whether it helps the organism survive better to pass on that trait. It is the small changes like color, size, shape, etc.

                                                              i.      Supposedly over time, these changes are evolution in action.

1.       There is little or no change in the genetics. So the organism either already had the genes or the new genetic material (through mutations) are added, but mutations have always been shown to be harmful.

b.      This is like how you can selectively breed a certain type of dog, but the dog is still a dog and not something more.

 

21.   Mutations

a.       This is supposed to be a major driving factor of evolution.

b.      Although some effects of mutations may be good in some respects, overall, those mutations are ultimately bad and may lose DNA and have not been shown to add to DNA the way the theory of evolution demands them to.

 

22.   Homology

a.       This is the study of similar body structures.

b.      Evolutionists say that when we see these homologous (similar) structures, it is evidence of common ancestry and evolutionary links between different kinds of organisms.

c.       Ultimately they are similar, because they have similar functions in the body.

d.      Genetics also does not help the evolutionist’s case.

 

23.   Junk DNA and Vestigial Organs

a.       Many evolutionists say that there is extra DNA in our genome, because it is leftover DNA from when we evolved from what we were in the past.

b.      Vestigial organs seem to not be useful today and so we have evolved away from those uses.

c.       Contrary to the view of evolution, there is turning out to be uses for much of that “extra” DNA and also for the vestigial organs.

 

24.   Why are there 2 genders?

a.       If evolution is true, organisms would have evolved from asexually reproducing (the process of dividing oneself to reproduce) to an advantage of having two genders.

b.      How did that become an advantage?

c.       It is a lot riskier to need both to reproduce in an environment where only the strong survive.

d.      How and why is the reproductive process so complicated?

 

25.   Mitochondrial Eve

a.       Through genetic studies of mitochondrial DNA, we can trace how people today are related and from how far back.

b.      The evidence shows that all people have a common mother initially reported to be 200,000 years ago, but mutation rates might be a lot higher and cause that number to be closer to 6,000 years ago.

c.       What caused Homo Sapiens to have evolved from one common couple?

d.      What caused the extinction of all the other pre-human ancestors?

 

26.   Pregnancy

a.       This is such a scientifically mind-blowing process.

b.      There are parts of the process that are still not understood why or how it happens.

c.       How did this process, which is needed for the continuation of life even become this complicated?

d.      Could it have even evolved?

 

27.   World Population Studies

a.       In studying populations, if Homo sapiens have supposedly been around for about 200,000 years, is there a reason that the population is only just now 7 billion?

b.      What are the factors that have affected the growth of populations to what it is today?

c.       The Bible is a historical record that also explains many of those factors and has been consistently confirmed by secular sources.

 

28.   Probability of Abiogenesis

a.       The process of making life from non-life is a highly complex issue.

b.      It is still uncertain about how this could have happened.

c.       There are many assumptions that we would have to make to even assume it to be possible.

d.      The probability is very small and even 5 billion years may not be enough time.

e.      So far, we have not been able to reproduce the same results in the lab.

 

29.   The Simplest Organism Known

a.       Life is complicated and the further we dig and the closer we look we find more and more complexity within all of life.

b.      What is the simplest organism known today?

c.       What is the simplest organism ever discovered, whether observed or in the fossil record?

d.      How simple is it?

e.      Could it have evolved?

 

Astronomy/Earth Science

30.   Comets

a.       Comets are known to be simply dirty snow balls.

b.      So each trip they take around the sun reduces them and thus they have a tail.

c.       So over time, comets should burn up and there should be no comets left.

d.      Evolutionists claim that the Oort Cloud replenishes the comets, but there is no evidence for the Oort Cloud’s existence.

 

31.   Creation of the Moon

a.       There are three main theories as to how the moon was naturally formed, but there are major problems with the different theories.

b.      The moon is so impactful to the earth especially throughout the Earth’s history, so this is a huge challenge for evolutionists.

 

32.   Dust on the Moon

a.       Each year, the moon collects space dust as it travels around the earth (and around the sun).

b.      If the moon were really old, how much dust would have been collected?

c.       Can it blow off the moon?

d.      Does it compact as rock on the surface of the moon?

 

33.   Our Receding Moon

a.       Each year, the moon is moving away from the year.

b.      If we calculate back through time, the moon would have been a lot closer to the earth causing tremendous tides that if strong enough would simply wash over the continents.

c.       Has the rate of the receding moon changed?

d.      How was the moon created?

 

34.   Finely Tuned Constants of the Universe

a.       There are many constant numbers that show up in physics and nature itself.

b.      If those numbers were just slightly off, then the universe would not have arranged itself the way it has and life would not be possible.

c.       Is this the results of random chance or God’s perfect design in creation.

 

35.   Perfect Placement for Life

a.       The earth is set in just the right place for Life to be possible.

b.      The large majority of the universe is unlivable and the chances needed for life are extremely slim.

c.       It is much easier to believe that God created the earth as unique rather than believe that random chance worked against the extremely slim chances.

 

36.   Star and Planetary Formation

a.       How did stars and planets form?

b.      This process has never been observed and so this process is based on many assumptions.

c.       There are many flaws in a naturalistic view of their formation.

 

37.   Tight Spiral Galaxies

a.       Over time these spiraling galaxies should fling their arms out away from the center and they would be spread out and not as direct and tight as they are.

b.      Enough time has passed to disband the spiral arms and naturalists have to bring in other explanations as to why they are still tight.

 

38.   Strong Magnetic Fields

a.       Magnetic fields protect the earth from harmful cosmic radiation.

b.      They are produced from spinning charged particles like the core of many planets.

c.       Many planets including the earth have very strong magnetic fields and those magnetic fields weaken over time.

d.      The magnetic fields of planets and stars are stronger than they should be for being billions of years old.

 

39.   Red Shift

a.       This is the phenomenon that when an object is moving away, the light (colors) that the object gives off are shifted to the red part of the electromagnetic spectrum.

b.      Is this a consistent phenomenon?

c.       Some evidence suggests that it is not.

 

40.   Our Sun

a.       How did our sun form?

b.      When did the fusion start?

c.       Is there a problem with the amount of angular momentum?

d.      If evolution is true, was it conducive for life on Earth over the past 5 billion years?

e.      How would it have changed over that time?

 

41.   Rotation and Revolutions of Moons

a.       Many of the moons in our solar system orbit backwards from the direction that the planet rotates.

b.      How is this difference in rotation and revolution possible?

c.       How have these moons formed and survived for as long as they have.

 

42.   Speed of Light

a.       Is the speed of light constant?

b.      Has it been different in the past?

c.       How is the cosmic background radiation so consistent if light can only travel as fast as it can?

 

43.   Canopy Theory

a.       This theory is based on the passage in scripture of God separating the waters from the waters and thus creating a canopy of water around the earth.

b.      This would have caused a greenhouse effect for the earth that would allow organisms to grow bigger, better, stronger and even older.

c.       Indications of larger fossils and long lives and more can be found in and/or are consistent with scripture.

d.      How could you explain the historical records of many people groups that talk about people living hundreds of years?

e.      How else could you explain things getting so big?

 

44.   The Big Bang

a.       Naturalists have long believed this to be the beginning of our known universe nearly 14 billion years ago.

b.      Since the universe is expanding, naturalists believe that all of the matter in our universe was once an infinitely small point and from that exploded and arranged itself to what we know today.

c.       How did the big bang happen?

d.      What caused the big bang to happen?

e.      What happened before the big bang?

f.        Did something come from nothing?

g.       What does infinitely small mean?

h.      Are there multiple universes?

 

45.   Aliens

a.       Many believe that if life has evolved here on earth, then life has evolved elsewhere in the universe.

b.      A lot of money is spent on the search for aliens, yet the nothing conclusive has been found.

c.       Is it a waste of money to even try to find aliens?

d.      Could there be Aliens?

e.      Where are they?

f.        How likely are we to find them?

 

46.   Oldest Trees

a.       What is the oldest tree?

b.      How do forests live and die?

c.       How old could a forest live theoretically?

d.      Most forests would only show evidence of only being a few thousand years old, and that is what we would expect if the flood occurred about 4000 years ago.

 

47.   Ocean Sediments and Salt

a.       There is not that much sediment in the ocean especially if there were more time for erosion to occur.

b.      Has the rate of erosion been less in the past?

c.       Over time the ocean would become more filled with sediments and salts, but currently the ocean is not that salty, another evidence of a young earth.

d.      Does the ocean’s saltiness fluctuate throughout time?

e.      How has the saltiness never gotten too bad to kill all of the organisms?

 

Chemistry/Physics

48.   Nucleus of an Atom

a.       How does the nucleus of an atom stay together?

b.      Why do protons stick together and not fly apart since “likes repel and opposites attract?”

c.       What are the strong and weak nuclear forces?

d.      Do we understand them or can we explain them?

 

49.   Elements of Life

a.       We are blessed to live on the earth especially with all the different resources and substances on the earth…and it’s not poisonous, but has all the benefits we need.

b.      Why are we able to find all of the lighter elements on the earth?

c.       Do the other planets have the entire mix of elements like we do or is earth unique?

 

50.   Quantum Physics

a.       What does quantum physics even know for sure?

b.      What can we prove by quantum physics?

c.       Some aspects of quantum physics even become philosophical.

 

51.   Dark Matter

a.       This is matter that has not been observed and it is still a mystery as to where it is, but we see the effects of it.

b.      Naturalists account for the fact that there are too much gravitational attractions by saying that there is this dark matter.

c.       Why can’t we see it?

d.      Would the equations and theories make more sense if it didn’t exist and the universe is younger than assumed to be?

 

52.   Dark Energy

a.       This is energy that is supposedly allowing the universe to expand outward yet it has never been observed.

b.      It simply has to be there for the universe to be expanding.

c.       70% of the universe is supposedly dark energy, 25% is supposedly dark matter and only 5% of the universe is the stuff we have observed and that we do know about.

d.      Is there a better explanation?

 

Mathematics

53.   Fibonacci Sequence in Nature

a.       This is a very simple mathematical sequence that can actually be found in many different aspects of nature and life around us.

b.      This is found in spirals, which consist of many parts of nature and some even describe this phenomenon as “God’s fingerprint” on creation.

c.       How would this have evolved/developed?

d.      Is there any reasonable, natural, logical explanation for why this might have evolved/developed?

 

54.   The Impossible Probability

a.       How improbable does something have to be to become impossible?

b.      To the evolutionist, with enough time and chances, anything is possible.

c.       The more unlikely something is, the more faith that you have to have to believe it.

d.      Is there always a chance?

 

55.   The Infinite

a.       How do we best describe the infinite?

b.      How is infinity possible?

c.       How is infinity in the past possible?

d.      Is God infinite?

e.      Is the universe infinite?

f.        Can we even grasp infinity?

 

56.   Fractals

a.       A fractal is a repeating pattern described or created by mathematics.

b.      How and why do fractals form?

c.       What is the naturalistic origin of fractals?

d.      Why do they exist?

 

History, Language and Culture

57.   Evolution of Languages

a.       How have languages have evolved?

b.      Are language studies able to estimate the age of our civilized societies and how old would that be?

c.       How would we have evolved modern language from primitive language?

 

58.   Legends of Creation

a.       Many cultures around the world have legends about how the earth was created.

b.      Most tie in these legends with their religion and beliefs.

c.       Are there similarities as to how the world was created?

d.      Similarities most likely point to common beginnings and sources.

e.      It appears that there are many cultures that have had a belief in One powerful, supreme creator God, but many have lost or perverted that belief.

 

59.   Legends of a Global Flood

a.       All around the world, there are cultures that have legends of a great flood.

b.      Some estimate that there are more than 270 flood legends.

c.       These flood legends appear to give credence the Biblical account of Noah’s ark and the global flood.

 

60.   Legends of Babel

a.       Many cultures around the world have descriptions of a great tower built to reach the heavens and that was not completed.

b.      How many legends are there and how do they compare?

c.       Which ones are the most logical and consistent?

 

61.   Connections to Babel

a.       There are many cultures around the world that can trace their lineages back to the same people around the tower of Babel and also even as far back as Noah.

b.      There are many similarities in very different cultures that could possibly stem from the one-world government and religion of Babel.

 

62.   Legends of Dragons

a.       There are a large quantity of legends about dragons, for example knights heroically fought and killed dragons to save the village and most importantly the princess.

b.      There are legends of the Chinese domesticating dragons to pull the carriages and we can easily see the rich heritage that dragons have left on the Chinese people.

c.       Were these dragons actually living dinosaurs?

d.      How common were they in the past?

 

63.   Religions in Every Culture

a.       It appears to be a human need to believe in something bigger and more purposeful to this life.

b.      We all believe something or believe in something.

                                                              i.      We All Have Faith.

                                                            ii.      If you do not have faith in something à you have faith that that something does not exist.

c.       Every person has a “God-shaped hole” in their heart that only Jesus can fill, although many people rebel from God and/or try to fill their need with a countless amount of other things.

 

64.   Pyramids, Ziggurats, Mounds, Henges, and Dolmens

a.       There is a countless number of structures built with human hands laying (and crumbling) all over the world.

b.      Why would people spend the time and manpower to build all of these structures?

c.       Most all of them have some religious purpose.

d.      These structures are an evidence of ancient intelligence and similarities having come from Babel.

 

65.   Constellations

a.       These amazing pictures in the night sky have always been around for especially ancient cultures to gaze upon and tell stories about.

b.      It is interesting that practically all use the same stories and pictures for the constellations and some say that the gospel is represented in the stars.

c.       Who came up with the constellations?

d.      Is the gospel actually written in the stars?

 

66.   Music

a.       If evolution is true, how and why did music evolve into an important part of our culture today?

b.      Why is there so much math involved in music?

c.       Why is it enjoyable?

 

67.   Art and Beauty

a.       Art and Beauty both can inspire and warm the soul.

b.      Is beauty solely for the purposes of mating or is there more to why something looks beautiful?

c.       What is art and why is it so mathematical?

 

68.   The Trustworthiness, Portrayal, and Interpretation of History

a.       The problem with history is that we can’t observe it again, because it’s gone.

b.      We have to have faith in those that teach us history.

c.       In being taught history, the teacher or presenter’s perspective and influence affects and colors the events.

d.      People groups will often still paint their own group/party/ethnicity in a good light.

 

69.   Oldest Records and Objects

a.       If Homo sapiens have been around for about 200,000 years, should we be able to find more remains and records and objects.

b.      What is the oldest known record or artifact?

c.       What assumptions are made in dating that artifact?

 

70.   Truth

a.       What is Truth?

b.      Does it matter?

c.       Can there be more than one Truth at a time?

d.      There is no absolute Truth – this statement is self-refuting.

e.      There is one Truth.

 

71.   Morality

a.       What is Morality?

b.      Why do we have morality?

c.       If evolution is true, how has morality evolved and why?

d.      Is morality absolute or relative?

e.      Relative morality breaks down and there is one set of absolute morality and that is as defined by God.

 

72.   Laws of Logic

a.       These rules help us to think appropriately and reason out the decisions that we make.

b.      If evolution is true, why have these laws come about?

c.       There is no reason for them, except in the case that God causes everything true to follow the laws of logic.

d.      The laws of logic are a set of information and information must have a source.

 

73.   Information Theory

a.       Where does information come from?

b.      Information Theory states that a mind or create has to come up with information and that it cannot come from random acts.

c.       If there were no God, how could we know anything?

 

74.   Who Are You?

a.       What makes up you?

b.      Are we physical and/or spiritual?

c.       Why do we have a thinking mind and how?

d.      Are we different than animals?

e.      How does evolution explain the jump that makes us so different than animals?

f.        Do we have a purpose in life?

 

75.   Religion

a.       Everyone believes in something even when they believe that they don’t believe in anything.

b.      Religion isn’t necessarily an organized social institution.

c.       It is solely based on what you believe.

d.      There are many other religions other than Christianity in the world today.

e.      But the Bible explains that there are only two religions: Accepting Jesus Christ or not.

 

If you have read this handout, you have seen a brief overview of the evidence and the challenges to evolution, now will you choose Jesus Christ or not?